| Overall Lighter Count |
| Player | Lighters |
| Bob Allen | 9 |
| Tom Bergeron | 6 |
| Paul Volts | 4 |
| Lee Vlcek | 3 |
| Tim Kennedy | 3 |
| Adam Westell | 2 |
| Chad Czyzewicz | 3 |
| Daniel Czyzewicz | 2 |
| Greg Carbon | 2 |
| Jack Czyzewicz | 2 |
| Jack Kazmierowicz | 2 |
| Nate Ristow | 2 |
| Ben Kazmierowicz | 1 |
| Carlos Espinoza | 1 |
| Cary Kazmierowicz | 1 |
| Dave Polmanteer | 1 |
| Mike Fisherkeller | 1 |
| Mike Price | 1 |
| Miles Moreau | 1 |
| Phil Kazmierowicz | 1 |
| Casey Cumby | 1 |
| Luke Kazmierowicz | 1 |
| Kevin Skonning | 1 |
| Year | Winner | Wins | Game |
| 2012 | Bob Allen | 2 | NLH |
| 2012 | Tom Bergeron | 1 | NLH |
| 2012 | Dave Polmanteer | 1 | NLH |
| 2013 | Tim Kennedy | 2 | NLH |
| 2013 | Jack Kazmierowicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2013 | Greg Carbon | 1 | NLH |
| 2014 | Bob Allen | 2 | NLH/NLO |
| 2014 | Jack Czyzewicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2014 | Phil Kazmierowicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2015 | Bob Allen | 2 | NLH |
| 2015 | Mike Price | 1 | NLH |
| 2015 | Mike Fisherkeller | 1 | NLH |
| 2016 | Tom Bergeron | 1 | NLH |
| 2016 | Jack Czyzewicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2016 | Paul Volts | 1 | NLH |
| 2016 | Daniel Czyzewicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2017 | Bob Allen | 2 | NLH |
| 2017 | Nate Ristow | 1 | NLH |
| 2017 | Lee Vlcek | 1 | NLH |
| 2018 | Nate Ristow | 1 | NLH |
| 2018 | Lee Vlcek | 1 | NLH |
| 2018 | Adam Westell | 1 | NLH |
| 2018 | Carlos Espinoza | 1 | NLH |
| Year | Winner | Wins | Game |
| 2019 | Chad Czyzewicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2019 | Ben Kazmierowicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2019 | Lee Vlcek | 1 | NLH |
| 2019 | Adam Westell | 1 | NLH |
| 2020 | Daniel Czyzewicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2020 | Cary Kazmierowicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2020 | Tim Kennedy | 1 | NLH |
| 2020 | Greg Carbon | 1 | NLH |
| 2021 | Paul Voltz | 1 | NLH |
| 2021 | Chad Czyzewicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2021 | Tom Bergeron | 1 | NLH |
| 2021 | |||
| 2022 | Miles Moreau*2021 Lighter | 1 | NLH |
| 2022 | Jack Kazmierowicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2022 | Tom Bergeron | 2 | NLH |
| 2023 | Bob Allen | 1 | NLH |
| 2023 | Tom Bergeron | 1 | NLH |
| 2023 | Paul Voltz | 2 | NLH |
| 2024 | Casey Cumby | 1 | NLH |
| 2024 | Luke Kazmierowicz | 1 | NLH |
| 2024 | Kevin Skonning | 1 | NLH |
| 2024 | Chad Czyzewicz | 1 | NLH |